Jump to content
IGNORED

Article: How To Decode and Play Dolby TrueHD Atmos on Windows and macOS


Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, seeteeyou said:

emotional words

Hi, sorry, my humour might have been lost in translation as horror. Six letters, both begin in h and end in r. But different emotions. 

 

But seriously, although I am familiar with anti-virus false positives, if a link is not making it through my anti-virus, then I find it difficult to recommend the link to others to use. 

Link to comment
8 hours ago, The Computer Audiophile said:

Yes, it's a disc authoring issue on the Blu-ray.

Bummer. Other than my marathon session last weekend to re-rip my older ATMOS music discs, I do not rip blu-rays much these days, just UHDs. I'd rather buy a download of ATMOS music and then archive the MKVs in offline backup. I have three backups of everything. So 120TB offline in two facilities for 40TB online. Maybe keeping more discs would be easier. But discs degrade over the decades. And I was asked by "house management" to reduce my physical "footprint" in the basement. 

 

If I remember right, my workarounds at this point would be:

  • Go straight to the m2ts file on the blu-ray, or
  • Create an ISO using DVDFab... if I remember right, this can be done as unprotected and with just the main title only, leaving blu-ray extras behind. Then run this reduced ISO through MakeMKV. 

I have no technical basis for these. They were learned by stubborn trial and error. My very last step would be to buy another disc from another country with different features. Maybe such a disc is authored separately / differently???

Link to comment
16 hours ago, The Computer Audiophile said:

 

I did some digging on this one. When I extracted the tracks and tried to convert using your settings, here's what I got. 

 

Screenshot 2024-08-06 at 3.28.08 PM.png

 

 

I may have used DRP outputting to Audacity, which captured it in my specific configuration, then exported to WAV from Audacity, for this album. Can't remember, but I know I was successful eventually getting WAVs of everything.

Thanks for taking a look, and this does look same as my results.  I believe all of the failed mkv's will decode if the TrueHD Presentation is set to 8 with output channel layout set to 5.1.2, but then the decoded files are missing the top channels for some reason.   I suspect top channels are missing because the information is excluded when True HD presentation is 8, but this is all very new to me and I need a better understanding.

 

BTW - I'm running into similar issues with the very next disc I selected to decode -  Joni Mitchell's Court and Spark.  

 

Link to comment

And how are you processing this one? Breaking the disc down into separate files first? Or keeping it simple and just ripping one MKV file with MakeMKV with all the record tracks as chapters in the one file, and just the TrueHD sound track? See Pink Floyd Animals image from my post above.

Link to comment

 

14 minutes ago, Carousel said:

And how are you processing this one? Breaking the disc down into separate files first? Or keeping it simple and just ripping one MKV file with MakeMKV with all the record tracks as chapters in the one file, and just the TrueHD sound track? See Pink Floyd Animals image from my post above.

Individual mka's.   Somehow I forgot about trying to process album in entirety.  Once I  joined the mka's and processed the album as whole, that decoded without problems. 

Thanks for asking.

 

 

Link to comment
1 hour ago, whoareyou said:

Thanks for taking a look, and this does look same as my results.  I believe all of the failed mkv's will decode if the TrueHD Presentation is set to 8 with output channel layout set to 5.1.2, but then the decoded files are missing the top channels for some reason.   I suspect top channels are missing because the information is excluded when True HD presentation is 8, but this is all very new to me and I need a better understanding.

 

This is part of a quirk I discovered when first testing the Dolby Reference Player to see if it would even work. It's how we discovered that importing a track other than track 1, into the DRP, required setting the presentation to 8 or less upon import, then changing it to 16 for playback. MMH can't make this adjustment for import and playback, thus the issue. 

 

 

1 hour ago, whoareyou said:

BTW - I'm running into similar issues with the very next disc I selected to decode -  Joni Mitchell's Court and Spark.  

 

 

No issues with Joni Mitchell (16 channel presentation > 5.1.2

 

Screenshot 2024-08-07 at 9.42.21 AM.png

Founder of Audiophile Style | My Audio Systems AudiophileStyleStickerWhite2.0.png AudiophileStyleStickerWhite7.1.4.png

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...

I'm looking to dip my toe into Atmos, but don't have a multi-speaker setup.  I have heard that Atmos can be experienced with normal headphones without any special speaker setups (I know it won't be the full experience, but I'm looking for at least a taste).  I've read lots of guides and found the Music Media Helper program on this site.  

Can someone tell me if I'm doing this right?  Here's my process.  First off, I've purchased the Dolby license through Dolby Access.  I have the "Dolby Atmos for Headphones" spatial sound option selected for my audio device in Windows 11. 

 

I'm using the Music Media Helper to decode the Atmos tracks from my Blu-ray audio MKVs to WAV, using "Stereo" for the output channel layout.  It's my understanding that this generates 2-channel files with Atmos metadata.  Now, since Dolby Atmos is enabled at the sound device level, can I use any media player to play back the files and get the Atmos effect?  I'm using VLC.  Is this right, or do I need to be using a special media player?  I am noticing a depth and separation that is not present in the stereo mixes, but I'm not sure if I'm getting the full or intended effect.        

I acquired the Dolby Reference Player, however it doesn't open WAV files (or MKV for that matter).  And I've heard multichannel players mentioned, such as JRiver and Audirvana.  Would these be preferable over VLC? 

 

Any feedback would be appreciated.

Link to comment
19 minutes ago, devoidzer0 said:

I'm looking to dip my toe into Atmos, but don't have a multi-speaker setup.  I have heard that Atmos can be experienced with normal headphones without any special speaker setups (I know it won't be the full experience, but I'm looking for at least a taste).  I've read lots of guides and found the Music Media Helper program on this site.  

Can someone tell me if I'm doing this right?  Here's my process.  First off, I've purchased the Dolby license through Dolby Access.  I have the "Dolby Atmos for Headphones" spatial sound option selected for my audio device in Windows 11. 

 

I'm using the Music Media Helper to decode the Atmos tracks from my Blu-ray audio MKVs to WAV, using "Stereo" for the output channel layout.  It's my understanding that this generates 2-channel files with Atmos metadata.  Now, since Dolby Atmos is enabled at the sound device level, can I use any media player to play back the files and get the Atmos effect?  I'm using VLC.  Is this right, or do I need to be using a special media player?  I am noticing a depth and separation that is not present in the stereo mixes, but I'm not sure if I'm getting the full or intended effect.        

I acquired the Dolby Reference Player, however it doesn't open WAV files (or MKV for that matter).  And I've heard multichannel players mentioned, such as JRiver and Audirvana.  Would these be preferable over VLC? 

 

Any feedback would be appreciated.

 

Hi @devoidzer0, it's actually much easier than you realize. 

 

If you've used MMH with Dolby Reference Player to decode the albums into stereo version WAV files, you are free to play them on any system that supports WAV files. You've already done the decoding, so don't need anything specific. Any media player app, DAC, phone, etc... will play the WAV files as intended. No need for the Dolby Access license etc...

 

Just play the stereo WAV files however you play all your other music. 

 

@joelha wrote about listening to stereo Atmos here as well

 

 

Founder of Audiophile Style | My Audio Systems AudiophileStyleStickerWhite2.0.png AudiophileStyleStickerWhite7.1.4.png

Link to comment
8 minutes ago, The Computer Audiophile said:

 

Hi @devoidzer0, it's actually much easier than you realize. 

 

If you've used MMH with Dolby Reference Player to decode the albums into stereo version WAV files, you are free to play them on any system that supports WAV files. You've already done the decoding, so don't need anything specific. Any media player app, DAC, phone, etc... will play the WAV files as intended. No need for the Dolby Access license etc...

 

Just play the stereo WAV files however you play all your other music. 

 

@joelha wrote about listening to stereo Atmos here as well

 

 

 

Very interesting..  You're right, I turned off Atmos in my audio device settings, and it sounds pretty much exactly the same!  Guess I just wasted 12 bucks on a Dolby Access subscription.  Ah well, live and learn.  Thanks for the info!

Link to comment
  • 1 month later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...